Q&A with Mike McKenna

Providing health care benefits is the single, largest employee-related expense for employers. Since 2000 the cost of health care benefits has increased 40 to 50 per cent.

For human resources representatives and CFO's, the burden of making the best decision in allocating these great sums only gets tougher-given the fast changing and increasingly complicated reality of health care coverage in the U.S.

The following Q & A, was compiled by Michael McKenna, president of Massachusetts-based Partners Benefit Group (www.partnersbenefitgroup.com), a full service employee benefits management company. Mr. McKenna has helped numerous companies beat the trend of skyrocketing health care benefits costs through the development of non-traditional plans. His Q&A offers employee benefits purchasers an at-a-glance resource for making smart, informed decisions.

Q. Is there any way we can save money on our healthcare benefits coverage costs?
A. Healthcare benefit plans are moving from traditional "managed care" (i.e., HMO's or other doctor-hospital network that acts as an intermediate between the person seeking care and the physician) to "consumer driven and other high deductible plans"-plans that require out of pocket payments by the insured before the insurer covers any claimed expenses.

The dilemma for employers is that most plans with affordable premiums now come with a high deductible for the employee, usually between $500 - $3,000 per year. The solution is to utilize the services of a broker who is also an experienced secondary payer, or familiar with the secondary payer market; is familiar with these plans; and can assess risk-which can enable the employer and the employee to creatively strategize with these deductible options thus reducing the impact of these deductibles.

These strategies offer employers the flexibility to creatively apply some of the savings they earn by choosing high deductible plans, reduce their insurance premium and use some of the savings to help the employee offset some of their annual deductible expense. For instance, a very simple plan might be to purchase a deductible of $1000 per year, the employer may have savings enough to cover the second $500 of the deductible and ask the employee to pay the first $500 of this deductible.

Q. What's a secondary payer?
A. Secondary payers (or 3rd party administrators) for this discussion are entities that ensure the accurate and timely payment for all or a portion of a deductible on the healthcare plan directly to the medical or dental provider who is owed this money, service all employee and medical provider inquiries and provide meaningful claims reporting to the employer.

Here's how it works: an employer selects an employee benefits management company, usually a sophisticated insurance agency, from whom they purchase their healthcare coverage plan. With the savings from the high deductible plan they purchase-they create a funding account that the employee benefits management company uses to administer payment of their employees' deductible, when employees file claims under their healthcare coverage.

Q. How much can these high deductible plans save us?
A. Savings, including the cost of the reimbursed claims, can range from 8% to 35%. It depends on what is currently being offered. Is the employer moving from an HMO to a deductible plan?

In some cases the strategy described here, admittedly, doesn't result in savings. But there are other definitions of "cost savings"-in these instances the option may be to use as leverage to negotiate administrative costs down, provide better data for the employer or even just improve the overall administration of the plan based on better technology and more service oriented procedures.

Q. Do high deductible/secondary payer plans mean more work for the employer providing the healthcare benefits coverage?
A. It's true that if employers want to drive down the cost of healthcare benefits coverage they have to work at it. But by engaging a benefits management company that acts as a secondary payer and allowing employees to interact with them, most of the healthcare benefits administration work is passed on to the management company. They will take care of processing claims, making payments to the medical care providers, handling late notices, administrating COBRA and serving as a resource on compliance.

Primarily the employers' role will be limited to holding enrollment meetings and funding the reimbursement account.

Q. Why doesn't my current broker provide these services?
A. Traditionally employers have purchased healthcare benefits from insurance generalists who essentially provided transactional service. With the vastly increased costs of healthcare benefits, the ongoing legislative changes and the sheer complexity of the products, the industry is moving from generalists to specialists/strategists.

Working with an informed, strategic healthcare benefits specialist is now virtually a requirement to achieve significant cost containment. A specialist goes beyond the role of the traditional insurance broker and transactional administrator. They create, develop and price out strategic plans based on a thorough understanding of risk and also have the ability to administer creative and attractive options working with high deductible healthcare coverage plans. For more information or to reach Michael McKenna, please call, toll-free, 877.993.5600 or e-mail him at mike@partnersbenefitgroup.com

Previous page